Alpine Garden Society

01386 554790
All topics Members' On-Line Discussion, All discussion threads for Any Other Topics

Any Other Topics: SOFT TUFA.

To make contributions or to send emails to other contributors Login


Hi all

Go to latest contribution by Geoffrey Alderton, 01 December 2011, 10:14. Go to bottom of this page.

Images on this page are shown as thumbnails. Click on an image to enlarge it.

Contribution from Geoffrey Alderton 19 November 2011, 20:14top / bottom of page

Hi all

Earlier this year I got hold of several decent sized lumps of Tufa. Two of the pieces are sandy coloured and quite soft. After jet washing, to remove all the loose stuff, I positioned them in the raised bed. They absorb a lot of moisture and moss grows on them very quickly. When drilling holes, 20mm dia X 100mm deep, in the two soft lumps, the weight of the drill was enough to get the drill bit down to the 100mm depth. My questions are; 1 Will the two soft sand coloured pieces eventually harden up and turn grey like my other tufa? 2 Is there a product I can put on the tufa to stop some, if not all, of the moss growing on the tufa. A product that won?t damage the plants.

Regards Geoff

Contribution from Geoffrey Alderton 20 November 2011, 11:06top / bottom of page

Hi again. These are the two pieces of soft tufa.

Regards Geoff.

Contribution from Margaret Young 20 November 2011, 18:56top / bottom of page

Here in Aberdeen we find that the soft tufa gets covered in moss very quickly, with no hindrance from anything we've tried ....while staying pretty sandy coloured and soft under the moss. The hard grey stuff stays hard and grey and gets much less moss on it......what will happen in your area, I can only guess at. There are a lot of plants which really enjoy a piece of tufa to root into... so your efforts will be rewared. I'd keep an eye onthe moss growth though.... it can take over if left alone for too long!

Contribution from Tim Ingram 21 November 2011, 08:36top / bottom of page

In the past, when sowing seed, a very dilute solution of potassium permanganate was recommended for controlling moss. I think this should work with tufa too, but I would imagine that in higher rainfall areas it would be a recurring problem.

Contribution from Luc Gilgemyn 22 November 2011, 16:17top / bottom of page
Mogeton ?

In our Forum of the VRV (Flemish Rock Garden society) there's an interesting topic of a member who has succesfully been testing a product called "Mogeton" - I'm not sure if this is available in the UK though.

Texts are in dutch, but Google translate might help !

Provided you use the right dosage, it seems to do the trick, without harming the plants...

Contribution from Geoffrey Alderton 22 November 2011, 16:54top / bottom of page

Hi all. Well I did a trip round my local garden centres looking for Potassium Permanganate or a product with it in the mix and came up with zero, but I will keep looking. I finished up purchasing a spray bottle of Bayer Garden Advanced MossKiller. Rapid Action. Results within three hrs. I thought with this on the label it has to be OK. I sprayed up my two pieces of soft, mossy tufa, came back three hrs later to have a look and I think the moss actually looked greener. I will give it forty eight hrs and then if its not sorting the moss out I will spray the two pieces a second time. Regards Geoff

Hi Luc. I will have a look for the product MOGETON and if available give it a try.

Thank you all for your tips and advice and passing them on to myself.

Regards Geoff.

Contribution from Geoffrey Alderton 22 November 2011, 17:33top / bottom of page

Hi all. Just had a quick search for Mogeton and it is available for use on hard surfaces in the UK.

A 1.5kg pack is Euro 155. with .75 kg packs from 40 to 80 so it's not cheap. I will keep looking to see if smaler packs are available.

Regards Geoff.

Contribution from Margaret Young 22 November 2011, 22:14top / bottom of page

To source Potassium Permanganate I'd try a pharmacist or perhaps a shop selling pond or tropical fish.

Should not be too hard to find. You'll only need a little bottle of crystals to try. A pinch of crystals in a watering can should be sufficient .... if it's going to work!

Good luck, Geoffrey,


Contribution from Brian Whyer 22 November 2011, 23:10top / bottom of page

Using too much Potassium permanganate will leave a coating of dark brown Manganese dioxide, which you may or may not like. Diluted vinegar kills moss on things like Sempervivum, but would partially dissolve some of the tufa I think.

My problem with tufa of indeterminate age, is how to keep it soft enough for drilling. I buy lumps, new or recycled, whenever I find a bit I like, but may not use it until a year or more later. Is keeping it dry enough or does it need sealing in polythene to slow down hardening?

Contribution from Harry Jans 29 November 2011, 18:50top / bottom of page
Contribution from Harry Jans 29 Nov. 2011

I have used very successful MgSO4 (Magnesium Sulphate)

It is a white powder you just sprinkle over the moss. Liverworth hates it! So far I have not seen any damage to plants, but it is always better to try it a bit before you use it on a bigger scale.

I have also used "Mogeton", which is very expensive but works super. It is better to spend a bit of money (if you calculate what you use) then a tufa garden over grown with moss. It is also possible to use it on seedpots with liverworth.

Contribution from Margaret Young 29 November 2011, 19:20top / bottom of page

Harry, thank you for responding to my plea for advice from the king of tufa!

Luc's suggestion seemed a good one and your comment adds weight: if that works for the finest tufa walls in Holland then it must be good. Thank you!

Contribution from Geoffrey Alderton 01 December 2011, 10:14top / bottom of page

Hi all. The Bayer Garden Advanced MossKiller seems to be doing the job, although we have had few heavy rain periods, since aplication. The moss has turned fawn coloured and is dying. The spray does not appear to have afected the couple of plants sprayed over. Erinus and Androsace. If the moss continues to die off I will continue with the spray on my other lumps of brown tufa.

As you can see from the pictures the moss is taking over.

Regards Geoff

Hi again as you can see I have posted one of the pictures twice.

This discussion Thread: SOFT TUFA. - To make contributions or to send emails to other contributors Login

Go to top of this page
Discussion Topic Any Other Topics
All topics Members' On-Line Discussion