Alpine Garden Society



01386 554790
All topics Members' On-Line Discussion, All discussion threads for Plants in the Wild

Plants in the Wild: Annapurna primulas March 2007

To make contributions or to send emails to other contributors Login

Started by: Susan Read

Large quantities of primula , pale lilac ?edgeworthii/nana/gracilipes. Any comments on name

Go to latest contribution by Susan Read, 30 October 2008, 16:59. Go to bottom of this page.

Images on this page are shown as thumbnails. Click on an image to enlarge it.

Contribution from John Richards 16 December 2007, 10:14top / bottom of page
Annapurna primulas

I have just picked up this thread about quantities of lilac primulas near Annapurna. It sounds as if they were probably P. nana (= edgeworthii = winteri) which is common there, but there are a number of other possibilities. Are there any photos? Queries as to name are usually best accompanied by a photo. John Richards

Contribution from Susan Read 22 February 2008, 16:11top / bottom of page
Annapurna primulas March 2007

I sent original comment with pic which AGS system seemed unable to cope with at the time! Have tried to attach picture file again. John I do have your book. Susan Read

Annapurna primulas March 2007

Contribution from Susan Read 22 February 2008, 17:10top / bottom of page
Annapurna primulas March 2007

Picture of a plant which may be different or just a variation?

Annapurna primulas March 2007

Contribution from John Richards 24 February 2008, 10:11top / bottom of page
Annapurna primulas

Hello Susan Yes, the upper photograph is the pink form of Primula nana (=edgeworthii) that is found in central Nepal. Further west it tends to be bluer. The lower photo, with flowers clustered on a stem is the familiar P. denticulata. John Richards

Contribution from Susan Read 24 February 2008, 19:19top / bottom of page
Annapurna primulas

Thanks for comments...area had a lot of smaller plants such as the one attached and nothing between as far as I could see Susan

Annapurna primulas

Contribution from Susan Read 24 October 2008, 17:33top / bottom of page
October 2008 east of Ghorepani...autumn primulas

Recent repeat visit to this area rewarded with good display. Could it be boothii subsp autumnalis?

October 2008 east of Ghorepani...autumn primulas

Contribution from John Richards 25 October 2008, 17:06top / bottom of page

Yes, I am sure P. boothii subsp. autumnalis is the right name for this. It was originally collected from near Ghorepane, south of Annapurna. It looks as if this plant has paler flowers than the clone 'Annapurna Autumn' in cultivation.

Contribution from Susan Read 30 October 2008, 16:59top / bottom of page

I think the plant had suffered from a hard frost...just a few miutes away a vertical bank in the shade was covered with smaller plants in better condition. Digital photography seems to affect the colour, especially where blue is concerned



This discussion Thread: Annapurna primulas March 2007 - To make contributions or to send emails to other contributors Login

Go to top of this page
Discussion Topic Plants in the Wild
All topics Members' On-Line Discussion